Quick Facts
Founded
2011
Denomination
Communion of Reformed Evangelical Churches
Service Times
Sunday 10:30 AM
Men's Ministry
Yes
Kids Ministry
Yes
Pastor Credentials
M.Div., Greyfriars Hall, New St. Andrews
10-Point Theological Scorecard
Christology
Is Jesus the only way? (John 14:6)
Nicene, Westminster Standards.
Strong
Scripture
Inerrancy affirmed? Final authority?
Inerrancy affirmed.
Strong
Men's Discipleship
Intentional formation for men?
CrossPolitic / men's Bible studies.
Strong
Soteriology
Faith alone? How is salvation presented?
Monergistic; Reformed.
Strong
Gender / Biblical Design
Biblical manhood and womanhood by God's design — patriarchal, complementarian, egalitarian, or affirming gender ideology?
Male-only officers; patriarchal household emphasis.
Strong
Leadership Structure
Male elders/pastors? Accountability?
Male elders.
Strong
Preaching Style
Expository or topical/therapeutic?
Expository with covenantal/redemptive-historical frame.
Strong
Mission Clarity
Great Commission central?
Kingdom-of-God orientation.
Strong
Cultural Alignment
DEI/CRT language? Social justice crowding out gospel?
Explicitly counter-cultural; Christian nationalism-adjacent.
Strong
Accountability Structure
Denominational home, elder plurality, or external network — is the pastor answerable to anyone?
Confirmed 2026-04: allsaintspresbyterian.com is a DomainMarket.com sales listing ($1,888) — domain lapsed. Church itself operational per CREC directory and Toby Sumpter's CrossPolitic public ministry; rating holds green but website URL needs replacement from CREC directory.
Strong
Assessment
All Saints Presbyterian is a CREC congregation in Lancaster, PA pastored by Rev. Toby Sumpter (co-host of CrossPolitic and a prominent voice in Moscow-adjacent Reformed circles). The church holds a confessional Reformed theology with explicit patriarchal household emphasis, male-only officers, and classical liturgical worship. Strong family culture and men's discipleship.
Sources & Evidence
Enrichment Notes
[2026-05-16 needs_review: Record lists Toby Sumpter as pastor, but Sumpter pastors King's Cross / Christ Church Moscow ID. Real Lancaster-area All Saints may be allsaints-church.com in New Holland PA. Verify and correct.]
No URL sources recorded for this church. Rating based on denominational defaults and/or directory-level metadata.
Transparency note: MOOP ratings are researcher judgments about publicly available theological and ecclesial evidence. They are not infallible. If a church's public posture has changed since our review, or if we've mis-read evidence, tell us — we publish corrections.
Last reviewed:
2026-05-16
— Annual review recommended
500 N Queen St, Lancaster, PA 17603
Visit Their Website