← Back to Dictionary
Antinomianism (Historic Heresy)
an-ti-NOH-mee-an-iz-um
noun (theological heresy)
From Greek anti (against) + nomos (law). Theological position teaching that Christians are not bound by the moral law in any sense, since they are under grace rather than law. Historic forms include various Gnostic-libertine sects (early); Johann Agricola's controversy with Luther (1530s-1540s); the English antinomian controversy with John Eaton and Tobias Crisp (17th c.); the New England Anne Hutchinson controversy (1636-1638). Distinguished from the Reformed-confessional rejection of justification by works.

📖 Biblical Definition

Theological position teaching that Christians are not bound by the moral law in any sense, since they are under grace rather than law. The term antinomianism (from Greek anti, against, + nomos, law) was coined by Martin Luther in the 1530s controversy with Johann Agricola, who had argued that Christians need not be addressed with the law (including the Ten Commandments) because the gospel alone produces sanctification. Luther sharply rejected this position and developed the principle that the moral law (particularly the Decalogue) retains its threefold use for the Christian: (1) civil use (restraining wickedness in the civil order); (2) pedagogical use (driving sinners to Christ by exposing their sin); (3) didactic / normative use (instructing the regenerate believer in the pattern of obedient Christian life). Historic forms of antinomianism include: (1) early Gnostic-libertine sects (some Gnostic groups in the second-third centuries held that since matter is evil and salvation is liberation of the spiritual self, the body's actions are morally indifferent, leading to libertine practice); (2) Johann Agricola's controversy with Luther (Wittenberg, 1530s-1540s; Luther's Six Disputations Against the Antinomians, 1538-1540, principal Reformation-era response); (3) the English antinomian controversy (early-mid 17th c.; John Eaton, Tobias Crisp, John Saltmarsh, and others taught variants of antinomianism; refuted by Richard Baxter, John Owen, and the broader Puritan-Reformed mainstream); (4) the New England Anne Hutchinson controversy (1636-1638; Hutchinson taught that the regenerate believer received direct revelations from the Spirit and need not heed the moral teaching of the church's ministers; tried at Boston; banished). The Reformed-confessional position (Westminster Confession XIX.6, on the third use of the law; Heidelberg Q. 86, on the believer's gratitude expressed in obedient law-keeping) explicitly rejects antinomianism: the believer is not under the law as a covenant of works (i.e., for justification) but is bound to obedience to the moral law as the rule of the Christian life. The Reformation's third use of the law doctrine is the substantive Reformed safeguard against antinomianism.

📜 Webster 1828 Definition

Theological position that Christians are not bound by the moral law since they are under grace; coined by Luther in Agricola controversy 1530s-1540s; historic forms (Gnostic libertine, Agricola, English antinomians, Anne Hutchinson); refuted by Reformation third-use-of-law doctrine.

expand to see more

ANTINOMIANISM, n. (theological heresy; Greek anti [against] + nomos [law]) Christians not bound by moral law in any sense since under grace. Term coined by Luther in 1530s controversy with Johann Agricola, who had argued Christians need not be addressed with law (including Decalogue) because gospel alone produces sanctification. Luther rejected; developed threefold use of law: civil, pedagogical, didactic/normative. Historic forms: (1) early Gnostic-libertine sects 2nd-3rd c.; (2) Agricola controversy Wittenberg 1530s-1540s; Luther's Six Disputations Against the Antinomians 1538-1540; (3) English antinomian controversy early-mid 17th c. (John Eaton, Tobias Crisp, John Saltmarsh); refuted by Baxter, Owen, Puritan-Reformed mainstream; (4) Anne Hutchinson controversy New England 1636-1638; tried at Boston; banished. Reformed-confessional position (Westminster XIX.6 third use of law; Heidelberg Q. 86) rejects antinomianism.

📖 Key Scripture

Romans 6:1-2"What shall we say then? Shall we continue in sin, that grace may abound? God forbid. How shall we, that are dead to sin, live any longer therein?"

Romans 3:31"Do we then make void the law through faith? God forbid: yea, we establish the law."

1 John 3:4"Whosoever committeth sin transgresseth also the law: for sin is the transgression of the law."

Galatians 5:13"For, brethren, ye have been called unto liberty; only use not liberty for an occasion to the flesh, but by love serve one another."

⚠️ Modern Corruption

Antinomianism: Christians not bound by moral law since under grace; refuted by apostolic teaching that grace establishes the law (Romans 3:31) and by Reformation third-use-of-law doctrine.

expand to see more

Antinomianism's substantive corruption is the denial that the moral law remains binding on the Christian as the rule of obedient life. The apostle Paul anticipates and refutes the position in Romans 6:1-2 (shall we continue in sin, that grace may abound? God forbid. How shall we, that are dead to sin, live any longer therein?) and Romans 3:31 (do we then make void the law through faith? God forbid: yea, we establish the law). 1 John 3:4 defines sin precisely as the transgression of the law (Greek anomia, lawlessness). The Reformed-confessional doctrine of the third use of the law (Westminster XIX.6) articulates the substantive position: the believer is not under the law as a covenant of works for justification (the doctrinal point Paul vigorously defends in Romans and Galatians) but is bound to obedience to the moral law as the rule of life expressing the believer's regenerate gratitude (Heidelberg Q. 86). The patriarchal-Reformed reader engages antinomianism as a substantive doctrinal error to be guarded against alongside its substantive opposite, legalism (justification by works of the law). The integrated Reformation position is justification by faith alone in Christ alone, with the same saving faith never alone but always producing obedient sanctification under the moral law as the rule of the Christian life.

🔗 Greek & Hebrew Roots

Greek anti + nomos; coined by Luther in Agricola controversy 1530s; historic forms; Reformed third-use-of-law refutation.

expand to see more

['Greek', '—', 'anti', 'against']

['Greek', '—', 'nomos', 'law']

['Greek', 'G458', 'anomia', 'lawlessness (1 John 3:4 definition of sin)']

Usage

"Antinomianism: Christians not bound by moral law since under grace."

"Historic forms: Gnostic libertine; Agricola controversy; English antinomians; Anne Hutchinson."

"Refuted by Reformation third-use-of-law doctrine (Westminster XIX.6; Heidelberg Q. 86)."

Related Words