The Counter-Reformation cannot be understood apart from the Reformation itself. When Luther, Calvin, and other Reformers called the church back to Scripture alone, faith alone, grace alone, Christ alone, and God's glory alone — Rome responded at the Council of Trent by formally condemning justification by faith alone and reaffirming the authority of tradition alongside Scripture. From a biblical perspective, the Counter-Reformation represents the institutional rejection of the Reformation's recovery of Gospel truth. Where the Reformers said sola Scriptura, Trent said Scripture and tradition. Where the Reformers said sola fide, Trent pronounced anathema on anyone who affirmed faith alone.
The term was well understood in Webster's day as Rome's organized response to Protestant reform.
REFORMA'TION, n. The change of religion from the corruptions of the church of Rome, begun by Luther, A.D. 1517. Note: Webster understood the Reformation as a recovery of true religion from corruption — the Counter-Reformation was Rome's attempt to resist that recovery.
• Romans 3:28 — "We hold that one is justified by faith apart from works of the law."
• Galatians 1:8 — "Even if we or an angel from heaven should preach to you a gospel contrary...let him be accursed."
• Ephesians 2:8-9 — "By grace you have been saved through faith...not a result of works."
Modern ecumenism pretends the Reformation divide has been bridged while Rome's official doctrines remain unchanged.
Modern evangelical leaders regularly declare that the Reformation is over and that Protestants and Catholics share the same Gospel. This is historically and doctrinally false. The Council of Trent's anathemas on justification by faith alone have never been rescinded. Rome still teaches that justification includes works, that the Mass is a propitiatory sacrifice, and that the Pope has supreme authority over all Christians. The Counter-Reformation did not end — it simply changed tactics, from military suppression to ecumenical absorption. Protestants who join hands with Rome without requiring Rome to repent of Trent are not pursuing unity — they are surrendering the Gospel the Reformers died to recover.
• "The Counter-Reformation was Rome's formal rejection of justification by faith alone — and its anathemas have never been revoked."
• "Modern ecumenism is the Counter-Reformation by other means — achieving through dialogue what Trent could not achieve through the Inquisition."