The Trinitarian heresy treating Father, Son, and Holy Spirit as three separate gods (rather than three Persons of one God). The position is the substantive opposite of Modalism / Sabellianism (which collapses three Persons to one). Tritheism over-emphasizes the threeness of the Persons at the expense of the substantive unity of the divine essence; Modalism over-emphasizes the unity at the expense of the substantive distinctions. Both fail orthodox Trinitarian confession. Historic outbreaks of Tritheism include (1) the sixth-century Monophysite Tritheist controversy among Eastern Christians (John Philoponus of Alexandria and his followers, who applied Aristotelian-philosophical species-and-individual categories to the Trinity in a way that produced effectively three divine individuals sharing the divine nature); (2) various medieval and early-modern moments when over-emphasis on the three Persons produced charges of Tritheism; (3) contemporary popular evangelical-charismatic over-emphases that sometimes effectively treat Father, Son, and Spirit as three distinct co-operating gods. The substantive orthodox confession (Athanasian Creed; Westminster Confession II.3) maintains the one divine essence shared by three Persons; the three Persons are not three gods nor three modes but three eternally distinct Persons consubstantial in the one divine essence. The Reformed-confessional tradition is rigorous on both halves: against Modalism, the substantive distinctions between Father, Son, and Spirit are eternal and substantive; against Tritheism, the divine essence is one and not three. The doctrine of perichoresis (Greek perichoresis, mutual indwelling; Latin circumincession) safeguards the substantive unity by maintaining the eternal mutual indwelling of the three Persons in the one divine essence.
Trinitarian heresy treating Father, Son, Holy Spirit as three separate gods; substantive opposite of Modalism/Sabellianism; orthodox doctrine maintains one essence in three eternal Persons; perichoresis safeguards substantive unity.
TRITHEISM, n. (Trinitarian heresy; Greek treis [three] + theos [god]) Treats Father, Son, Holy Spirit as three separate gods. Substantive opposite of Modalism / Sabellianism (collapses three to one). Tritheism over-emphasizes threeness at expense of unity; Modalism over-emphasizes unity at expense of distinctions. Historic outbreaks: (1) 6th-c. Monophysite Tritheist controversy among Eastern Christians (John Philoponus of Alexandria applied Aristotelian species-and-individual categories to Trinity producing three divine individuals); (2) various medieval and early-modern moments; (3) contemporary popular evangelical-charismatic over-emphases. Orthodox confession (Athanasian Creed; Westminster Confession II.3): one divine essence shared by three Persons; three eternally distinct Persons consubstantial in one divine essence. Doctrine of perichoresis (mutual indwelling) safeguards substantive unity.
Deuteronomy 6:4 — "Hear, O Israel: The LORD our God is one LORD."
Mark 12:29 — "And Jesus answered him, The first of all the commandments is, Hear, O Israel; The Lord our God is one Lord."
1 Corinthians 8:6 — "But to us there is but one God, the Father, of whom are all things, and we in him; and one Lord Jesus Christ, by whom are all things, and we by him."
James 2:19 — "Thou believest that there is one God; thou doest well: the devils also believe, and tremble."
Tritheism treats Father, Son, and Holy Spirit as three separate gods; over-emphasizes threeness at expense of substantive unity; condemned by orthodox tradition.
Tritheism's substantive corruption is the separation of the three Persons of the Trinity into three gods. Scripture maintains the substantive unity of God throughout (Deuteronomy 6:4, the great Shema; 1 Corinthians 8:6, Paul's Christianized version; James 2:19, the affirmation of monotheism). The orthodox confession safeguards both the unity (one divine essence, one being, one substance) and the distinction (three eternally distinct, co-equal, consubstantial Persons). Tritheism fails the unity-half of this confession; Modalism fails the distinction-half. The doctrine of perichoresis (the eternal mutual indwelling of the three Persons in the one divine essence) is the substantive safeguard against Tritheism: the three Persons are not three gods sharing a common nature (which would be Tritheism), but three Persons eternally indwelling one another in the unity of the one divine essence.
Three separate gods; substantive opposite of Modalism; condemned by orthodox tradition; perichoresis safeguards unity.
['Greek', '—', 'treis', 'three']
['Greek', '—', 'theos', 'god']
['Greek', '—', 'perichoresis', 'mutual indwelling; the orthodox safeguard against Tritheism']
"Tritheism: Father, Son, Holy Spirit as three separate gods."
"Substantive opposite of Modalism / Sabellianism."
"Orthodox doctrine: one divine essence in three eternally distinct Persons; perichoresis safeguards unity."