See also: Gift of Prophecy
The gift of prophecy is the Spirit-given capacity to speak forth a message from God—whether the foretelling of things to come or, more broadly, the forth-telling of God’s truth for edification, exhortation, and comfort. In the Old Testament the prophets were the authoritative mouthpieces of God, whose word was the very Word of the LORD, binding and infallible, attested by perfect fulfillment, and the false prophet was put to death. In the New Testament, prophecy appears among the gifts, ranked by Paul above tongues because it edifies the church in understandable speech: he that prophesieth speaketh unto men to edification, and exhortation, and comfort. The great interpretive question is the nature and authority of New Testament congregational prophecy. Cessationists hold that prophecy, as a revelatory gift conveying the word of God, was infallible and authoritative like its Old Testament counterpart, served to lay the foundation of the church alongside the apostles, and ceased with the completion of the canon, since ongoing infallible revelation would rival the closed Scripture. Some continuationists, by contrast, distinguish the foundational, canonical prophecy of the apostles from a lesser, fallible, Spirit-prompted congregational prophecy that must be weighed and tested and carries no canonical authority. All orthodox parties agree on the decisive guardrail: no claimed prophecy may add to, contradict, or rival the closed and sufficient Scripture, every prophetic claim must be tested by the Word, and the spirits must be tried, for many false prophets are gone out into the world. Prophecy, rightly understood, always serves and submits to the written Word; it never supplants it.
Webster 1828 defines PROPHECY as a foretelling; prediction; and in Scripture, a declaration of something to come, or the gift and exercise of the prophetic office.
PROPHECY, n. — 1. A foretelling; prediction; a declaration of something to come. As God only knows future events with certainty, no being but God or some person informed by him, can utter a real prophecy. 2. In Scripture, a book of prophecies; a history. 3. Preaching; public interpretation of Scripture; exhortation or instruction.
PROPHESY, v.i. — ...2. To utter predictions. 3. To preach; to instruct in religious doctrines.
1 Corinthians 14:3 — "But he that prophesieth speaketh unto men to edification, and exhortation, and comfort."
1 Corinthians 14:29 — "Let the prophets speak two or three, and let the other judge."
1 Thessalonians 5:20-21 — "Despise not prophesyings. Prove all things; hold fast that which is good."
1 John 4:1 — "Beloved, believe not every spirit, but try the spirits whether they are of God: because many false prophets are gone out into the world."
Prophecy is gravely abused when claimed “words from the Lord” are treated as infallible and binding, rivaling or overriding the closed canon—and when prophets escape the biblical tests by which they must be judged.
The most dangerous corruption of prophecy is the elevation of claimed “words from the Lord” to an authority that rivals or overrides Scripture. Wherever a prophet’s utterance carries the binding weight of “thus saith the Lord,” wherever congregations order their lives by fresh revelations, wherever the closed canon is in practice reopened by a steady stream of new directives, the sufficiency and finality of the written Word are imperiled. This is the very danger cessationists press most urgently: God’s public, infallible revelation is complete in Scripture, and any claim of new revelation of equal authority undermines the perfection of the canon. The Word is finished; the church needs no fresh oracles to supplement it.
A second corruption is the evasion of the biblical tests by which all prophecy must be judged. Scripture never bids the church accept prophetic claims uncritically; on the contrary, it commands that prophets be weighed, that the others judge, that all things be proved and only the good held fast, that the spirits be tried, and—most severely—that the prophet whose word does not come to pass has spoken presumptuously and is not to be feared. The modern prophetic movements that traffic in confident predictions, quietly forgetting the failed ones, would not survive the application of these tests. Whether one expects prophecy to continue or not, the guardrails are fixed and binding: no prophecy may contradict or rival the Word, every claim must be tested by it, and the false prophet stands condemned. Prophecy, where genuine, always serves the Scripture and submits to it; the moment it claims to stand beside or above the Word, it has become a counterfeit.
The gift is prophēteia (a speaking-forth of God’s message), to be judged (diakrinō) and tested (dokimazō), never set above the Word.
['Greek', 'G4394', 'prophēteia', 'prophecy, the speaking forth of God’s message']
['Greek', 'G1252', 'diakrinō', 'to judge, discern (let the others judge)']
['Greek', 'G1381', 'dokimazō', 'to test, prove (prove all things)']
['Greek', 'G3618', 'oikodomeō', 'to build up, edify (prophecy edifies the church)']
"The gift of prophecy speaks forth God’s message for edification, ranked by Paul above tongues because it is understood."
"Claimed prophecy that rivals or overrides the closed canon is a grave corruption of the gift."
"Scripture commands that all prophecy be weighed and tested—the false prophet whose word fails stands condemned."
Chapters of the reading Bible where this entry is linked.