See also: Keys of the Kingdom
The keys of the kingdom are the authority Christ committed to His church to open and to shut the kingdom of heaven—to admit the penitent and to exclude the impenitent—exercised in His name and according to His Word. The Reformed tradition distinguishes two keys. The key of doctrine is the ministry of the Word: by the faithful preaching of the gospel the kingdom is opened to believers and shut against the unbelieving and hardened. The key of discipline is the exercise of church government: by admonition, suspension from the sacraments, and excommunication, the church binds and looses, retaining or remitting sins ministerially as the Word directs. These keys were given first to Peter as he confessed Christ, then to all the apostles, and through them to the church and her officers in every age—not to one man as a personal possession, but to the ordered assembly. The keys do not create grace or forfeit it at human whim; they declare and apply what God has already decreed in heaven, so that what the church rightly binds on earth is bound in heaven. The power is real but ministerial, spiritual but not civil, and it is wielded for the building up of the saints and the reclaiming of the lost.
Webster 1828 defines KEY as an instrument for shutting and opening, and figuratively as the power of governing; the “keys of the kingdom” denote ecclesiastical authority to admit and exclude.
KEY, n. — 1. An instrument for shutting or opening a lock. 2. That which serves to open or explain. 3. Figuratively, the power of governing and giving access; as the keys of the kingdom of heaven, the power of admitting into or excluding from the church.
The keys denote the authority of the ministry to dispense the Word and the discipline by which the kingdom is opened and shut.
Matthew 16:19 — "And I will give unto thee the keys of the kingdom of heaven: and whatsoever thou shalt bind on earth shall be bound in heaven: and whatsoever thou shalt loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven."
Matthew 18:18 — "Verily I say unto you, Whatsoever ye shall bind on earth shall be bound in heaven: and whatsoever ye shall loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven."
John 20:23 — "Whose soever sins ye remit, they are remitted unto them; and whose soever sins ye retain, they are retained."
Isaiah 22:22 — "And the key of the house of David will I lay upon his shoulder; so he shall open, and none shall shut; and he shall shut, and none shall open."
Rome turns the keys into a personal papal monopoly, forging from Matthew 16 a doctrine of supremacy; the modern church errs oppositely, surrendering the keys entirely so that none are bound and none excluded.
The most ancient corruption of the keys is the papal one. From the promise to Peter, Rome constructed an entire empire of jurisdiction—the keys as the personal property of one bishop and his successors, the power to bind and loose centralized in a single chair, and finally the claim to remit sins and dispense the treasury of merit. But Christ gave the same binding and loosing to all the apostles in Matthew 18, and located the exercise of discipline in the church, not in a solitary prelate. The keys belong to the ordered assembly under Christ, not to a man who claims to hold them alone.
The opposite and more fashionable corruption is to throw the keys away. A church that never binds anything, never excludes anyone, and never declares the terms on which the kingdom is opened or shut has functionally renounced the authority Christ gave her. In the name of grace she abolishes discipline; in the name of love she leaves the impenitent at the table and the heretic in the pulpit. To lose the keys is not humility—it is unfaithfulness to a trust the Lord Himself committed to His bride.
The imagery reaches back to Isaiah 22, where the key of the house of David is laid on the steward’s shoulder—a type fulfilled in Christ, who shares His stewardship with His church.
"Christ gave the keys of the kingdom to His church, not to a single bishop claiming them as private property."
"A church that binds nothing and looses nothing has dropped the keys of the kingdom in the dust."
"By the key of discipline the impenitent man was barred from the table until he should repent."