← Back to Dictionary
Exclusive Psalmody
ek-SKLOO-siv SAHL-moh-dee
noun phrase (Reformed-confessional worship position)
The Reformed-confessional position (historically held in Scottish-Presbyterian and Reformed-Presbyterian traditions) that only the 150 inspired Psalms (and possibly other canonical songs) are to be sung in the public worship of God. Distinguished from inclusive psalmody (psalms preferred but other songs permitted) and from broad-evangelical hymnody (hymns and contemporary songs as principal worship songs).

📖 Biblical Definition

The Reformed-confessional worship position that only the 150 inspired Psalms (and in some forms other canonical songs such as the Song of Moses, Mary's Magnificat, etc.) are to be sung in the public worship of God. The position has been historically held in the Scottish-Presbyterian and Reformed-Presbyterian traditions (the Reformed Presbyterian Church of North America, RPCNA; the Free Presbyterian Church of Scotland; and various smaller Reformed-Presbyterian bodies) and was the substantive position of Scottish Presbyterianism from the Reformation through the late nineteenth century. The substantive theological grounds: (1) the regulative principle requires positive scriptural command for worship elements; the singing of inspired psalms is positively commanded (Colossians 3:16; Ephesians 5:19; James 5:13; Psalm 95; 100; etc.); the singing of uninspired human compositions is not positively commanded and therefore is not warranted by the regulative principle; (2) the Psalms are the divinely-inspired praise-book of God's people, comprehensively suitable for every season of the believer's life and the church's life; (3) singing uninspired human compositions risks introducing doctrinal error and unauthorized content into worship. The substantive Reformed-confessional response from the broader hymnody-permitting tradition (the majority Reformed-confessional position in the contemporary world): the regulative principle commands the substantive activity of praise singing without restricting the inspired-Psalter content; the apostolic phrase psalms and hymns and spiritual songs (Colossians 3:16; Ephesians 5:19) substantively permits both Psalms and other songs; the universal church's substantive practice has substantially included non-Psalm hymns from the patristic era onward. The patriarchal-Reformed reader engages the substantive intra-Reformed discussion with appropriate care; both positions are held within the broader Reformed-confessional tradition with substantive theological-pastoral integrity. The contemporary recovery of psalm-singing in Reformed-confessional churches (the metrical Psalter, the singing of psalms alongside hymns) is substantively valuable regardless of which side of the exclusive-psalmody debate a particular church holds.

📜 Webster 1828 Definition

Reformed-confessional position (historically Scottish-Presbyterian and Reformed-Presbyterian) that only the 150 inspired Psalms (and possibly other canonical songs) are to be sung in public worship; distinguished from inclusive psalmody and broad-evangelical hymnody.

expand to see more

EXCLUSIVE PSALMODY, n. phr. (Reformed-confessional worship position) Only the 150 inspired Psalms (and in some forms other canonical songs) are to be sung in public worship. Historically held in Scottish-Presbyterian and Reformed-Presbyterian traditions; substantive Scottish Presbyterian position from Reformation through late 19th c. Grounds: (1) regulative principle requires positive scriptural command; psalm-singing positively commanded; uninspired-human-composition singing not positively commanded; (2) Psalms are divinely-inspired praise-book of God's people; (3) singing uninspired compositions risks doctrinal error. Reformed hymnody-permitting response: regulative principle commands activity without restricting content; psalms and hymns and spiritual songs (Colossians 3:16; Ephesians 5:19) substantively permits both; universal church's practice has substantially included non-Psalm hymns from patristic era.

📖 Key Scripture

Colossians 3:16"Let the word of Christ dwell in you richly in all wisdom; teaching and admonishing one another in psalms and hymns and spiritual songs, singing with grace in your hearts to the Lord."

Ephesians 5:19"Speaking to yourselves in psalms and hymns and spiritual songs, singing and making melody in your heart to the Lord."

James 5:13"Is any among you afflicted? let him pray. Is any merry? let him sing psalms."

Psalm 95:1-2"O come, let us sing unto the LORD: let us make a joyful noise to the rock of our salvation. Let us come before his presence with thanksgiving, and make a joyful noise unto him with psalms."

⚠️ Modern Corruption

Exclusive psalmody is a substantive intra-Reformed-confessional position; the broader Reformed-confessional tradition permits both psalms and hymns; both positions are held with substantive theological-pastoral integrity.

expand to see more

Exclusive psalmody is one of the substantive intra-Reformed-confessional positions on the question of what is sung in public worship. The substantive Scottish-Presbyterian historical position holds exclusive psalmody; the broader Reformed-confessional tradition (the substantive majority position in contemporary Reformed-confessional churches) permits both psalms and hymns. The patriarchal-Reformed reader engages the discussion with appropriate care: substantive engagement with both positions; recognition of the substantive Reformed-confessional unity on the regulative principle and on the substantive value of psalm-singing; respectful disagreement on the specific question of whether psalm-singing is exclusive. The contemporary recovery of psalm-singing in many Reformed-confessional churches (with metrical Psalters and substantial psalm-singing alongside hymn-singing) is substantively valuable regardless of which side of the exclusive-psalmody debate a particular church holds. The substantive concern is the substantive recovery of psalm-singing as a substantive part of Reformed-confessional worship.

🔗 Greek & Hebrew Roots

Reformed-confessional position; 150 Psalms only in worship; Scottish-Presbyterian historical position; substantive intra-Reformed discussion with broader hymnody-permitting tradition.

expand to see more

['Greek', 'G5568', 'psalmos', 'psalm, song']

['Hebrew', 'H4210', 'mizmor', 'psalm']

['English', '—', 'Psalter', 'the 150 inspired psalms as a book']

Usage

"Exclusive psalmody: only the 150 inspired Psalms (and possibly other canonical songs) sung in public worship."

"Historically held in Scottish-Presbyterian and Reformed-Presbyterian traditions."

"Substantive intra-Reformed-confessional discussion with the broader hymnody-permitting tradition."

Related Words